By writing for Wikipedia, students learn more than a "traditional test": Luz María Silva

Translate this post

Photo from Luz Maria Silva, CC BY-SA 4.0.
Photo from Luz Maria Silva, CC BY-SA 4.0.

Using Wikipedia in education is far from a new or novel idea. “Murder, Madness, and Mayhem” was one of, if not the first, to do it in 2008. The Wikimedia Foundation’s Public Policy Initiative trialed an organized idea in 2010–11. Today, there’s both a Wiki Education Foundation and a Wikipedia Education Program.
Yet it is still a brave academian who tries to bring the unfamiliar tool of Wikipedia into the classroom.
Professor Luz María Silva is of them: her students have been allowed used Wikipedia in the classroom for the last three years. Silva, a Spanish Wikipedia editor herself, has been assigning a Wikipedia article to her students learning about the socio-political history of Mexico. The assignment comes in lieu of a midterm exam, and Silva is supported in her efforts by Wikimedia Mexico.
Silva says of her students that “I am very lucky to work with people as smart as [them]. They are young and committed to their work, and as they frequently use Wikipedia, they find [it] fascinating to contribute to a familiar source, something that many of them had never considered possible before. I hope that, little by little, their conviction will lead them to become active Wikipedians.”
These individuals have certainly had a measurable impact on the site: they have written 221 articles in total, an average of about 36 per semester. The 40 this year have been on a variety of topics, such as “Mujeres en la Guerra de Independencia (Mexico),” or “Women in the Independence War (Mexico).” The article, in lockstep with current historical scholarship, contains several short biographies of important women in the context of Mexico’s fight for independence from Spain.
There are another 15 biographies, six on historical sites, five on services (“hospitals, electricity, the circus, and entertainment”), and three on old manuscripts and books, along with several others.
Regular Wikipedians have both helped and hindered the process. On the one hand, when one student “embedded paragraphs from two sources and thought that just citing them as references was enough,” Wikimedia Mexico and a Spanish Wikipedia administrator taught her “how to [properly attribute] research, which is knowledge that will be with her for the rest of her life and ultimately helped her article stay online. It was a very happy ending.”
On the other, Silva says, occasionally “there’s an incident that makes you and your work feel exposed to the opinion of strangers …  it’s quite frustrating, even if my students get a satisfactory mark on their record. There’s a real pain to see an article erased without further explanations.”
In any case, Silva believes that Wikipedia benefits her students. By “learning to write an article, [they] develop analytical skills, problem solving, and [how] to face a blank page to write without judgment.”
And by the end of the assignment, they end up “learning more than a traditional test.”
Ed Erhart, Editorial Associate
Wikimedia Foundation

Our thanks go to Iván Martínez of Wikimedia Mexico for the original interview, published in the Wikimedia Education Newsletter, and to Andycyca for translating it from the Spanish.

Archive notice: This is an archived post from, which operated under different editorial and content guidelines than Diff.

Can you help us translate this article?

In order for this article to reach as many people as possible we would like your help. Can you translate this article to get the message out?

Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

What a wonderful idea!

Great job did by Professor Luz María Silva. Hats off you.

It’s indeed a wonderful idea and I would like to know more about it. What age children were writing these articles and how did they go about it.

My students are university students from 19, 20 years old on average. They have to choose a topic that interests them, not having an article in Wikipedia, which is encyclopedic interest on the history of Mexico from pre-Columbian times the Porfiriato, which is the period covered by our course.
They tell me and show me the issue is not in Wikipedia, but that there are enough sources. They choose between writing alone and teach your article at the end or work it closer to me. They should upload your text before I see it.

Bishal Ramauli Magar
Thanks you are very kind

Tommye Rodrigues
Thanks you

Yes, it is a good idea that students write an article in Wikipedia. The teacher has to follow the entire process because Wikipedia is a widely read encyclopedia and therefore can not have errors. We must protect the research that the student, teach it to present ideas without personal opinions, citing sources and especially to raise good article. It is a very educational process for students and for teachers. It is also very exciting to feel a deep human relationship between teacher and students is when they finally see their work published on Wikipedia, which is a source they use… Read more »