For almost a decade, the Wikimedia Foundation’s Community Resources team has been funding people and organizations pursuing our vision: Imagine a world in which every single human being can freely share in the sum of all knowledge.
In the last five years alone, we’ve given out over 35 million US dollars across almost 80 countries.
Our efforts to understand the impact of these grants began five years ago, and has been primarily focused on short-term outputs, such as the number of articles or editors on Wikimedia projects. But while these metrics are important, they are not sufficient to understand the holistic impact of our grant programs.
The impact of Wikimedia grants spans the online to offline, the tangible to intangible, the transactional to transformational. So our evaluation of grants has needed to evolve to include longer-term outcomes. These are the ripple effects of grantee work that are hard (and sometimes impossible) to measure in shorter time-frames such as month or a year. To this end, Community Resources launched a Grants Impact project in 2017, a qualitative inquiry into learning more about these longer-term outcomes.
One of the things we discovered is that grants have played a role in enabling humanity to partake in our collective cultural heritage.
Alright, that’s pretty dense. Let’s break it down.
We can think of heritage as something handed down from the past. Inventions, habits, rituals, monuments, art, food, language are all examples of a community’s heritage. For a particular community, the collection and evolution of these pieces over time becomes that community’s cultural heritage.
In its transmission, cultural heritage serves as an inter-generational link between the past, present and future, communicating both tangible and intangible aspects of identity. But while heritage is typically described at a community level, like African-American heritage within the United States, humanity also has a kind of collective cultural heritage. It’s the long arc of human history that helps us understand who are are as a society, relative to who we were. And that collective cultural heritage is part of what Wikimedia is curating in its “sum of all knowledge.”
Our first set of case studies highlight six stories about how Wikimedia grants have documented, liberated, or engaged with cultural heritage from around the world.
They have also enabled communities to confront oppressive narratives or traumatic histories, such as Wikimedia Argentina’s work to acknowledge state terrorism and the trauma caused by those crimes against humanity, a trauma that is part of the Argentine collective memory.
In the end, these these stories offer a glimpse into the larger “so what?” of Wikimedia’s vision: what happens in a world where knowledge is freely shared?
We don’t know the answer to that question yet. We don’t know the larger impact of Wikimedia. But while the restoration of pride in one’s identity, the revitalization of language, or the empowerment of people aren’t the explicit goals of Wikimedia, these stories begin to show us what might be possible.
Heritage constitutes a source of identity and cohesion for communities disrupted by bewildering change and economic instability. –UNESCO
There are so many more outcomes. We also discovered that grants have played a role in:
- Building community: Deepening the trust, cooperation, and connection of communities around the world.
- Improving diversity and inclusion: Bringing in those who were previously left out, creating a more diverse and globally representative movement.
- Expanding the free knowledge ecosystem: Convincing knowledge stewards to open their doors, thereby expanding the ecosystem that is working toward free and open knowledge.
Over the next few months will be publishing more case studies that highlight grantee work in each area. Our hope is that by bringing new information into the discussion on “What is impact?”, we will evolve the thinking on impact, grants, and role Wikimedia can play (and has played) as a social movement.
Sati Houston, Senior Strategist, Community Resources